Skip to content


6 February, 2008

Today’s free Metro featured an article on transexuality and transpeople, or more accurately, transmen; girls who want to be boys.

This sparked off a series of discussions amongst some of my students, and we have had a day full of debates on what it means to be a transperson and what the differences are between gender, identity and sexuality.


Not surprisingly, one of my female learners came to me later, in private and asked me the million dollar question, “how do you know if you might be one of these transpeople?”

“K” as we’ll call her, is what you would class as a tomboy, she could easily be mistaken for a boy and does readily confess to being a lesbian. She dresses in a  non gender specific manner and has non of the more feminine nuances that you would normally see in an 17 year old girl. I gave her the article to read, especially the interviews with the three transmen that the paper featured and then gave her a print out of my post dated 1st August, which had comments from transmen.

I don’t profess to be an expert on gender studies or sexuality or anything to do with transsexuality, I suppose being gay I have a little insight into the issues surrounding acceptance of anything outside of what some people class as “the norm”. I did feel a little out of my depth answering questions but after a little reasearch on the internet, found some numbers and organisations that “K” could phone to get help and advice.

The article itself (click on the thumbnail to see the full article) wasn’t really an indepth look at transmen, it was a short sound bite that didn’t really offer anything; no real insights as to what it feels like for a girl, there’s a song in there somewhere, that feels she ought to be a man.

I feel angry sometimes that papers like this trivialise and try to offer to the general public a condensed version of what is a very complex and intricate set of emotions and issues for those whom it affects. Some things cannot be summarised without them being damaged and in my view this is one of them. Exposure doesn’t always lead to common acceptance and understanding, it nearly always leads to ill informed ignorance and a general population who think they now know something about an issue that they really don’t. I know there are those who say that some knowledge is better than none, but on the otherside of the scales, a little knowledge can also be dangerous.

9 Comments leave one →
  1. MindyLou permalink
    7 February, 2008 10:44 PM

    Sorry – i’m gormy. You have links!

  2. MindyLou permalink
    7 February, 2008 10:39 PM

    Cool cool. Had a little snoop around your blog before i jumped in the bath – do you have copies of the articles that you did for Helium?

  3. 7 February, 2008 10:17 PM

    I just hope she was open and honest with the doctor.

    ps I’ve found some footage on YouTube of a Transman, and links to his website, she might find it interesting, I’ll email you the link tomorrow!

  4. MindyLou permalink
    7 February, 2008 10:15 PM

    She went to the docs today. Didn’t really say much about it, but has another appointment next Thurs.

  5. 7 February, 2008 9:31 PM

    I did hear today from “M” on reception that “K” has made an appointment to see her doctor. She also confided to “M” that she doesn’t want to lose her breasts, so, I think she may have second thoughts. Only time will tell.

  6. MindyLou permalink
    7 February, 2008 8:50 PM

    Yeah i’m trying to convince her to take things one step at a time. I think everyone goes down different paths when exploring their sexuality when trying to establish who it is they really are.

  7. 6 February, 2008 10:38 PM

    It’s a discussion I’ve been having all week, with a class on Tuesday too, we covered sexuality, gender and identity and spent quite some time on transexuality, I had some good searching questions. With “K”, she is still quite young and I wonder how much of this is her way of exploring the different aspects and avenues open to her as part of her sexuality. She may decide in a few years that she actually doesn’t want to be male and may find contentment in accepting fully that she is just gay. I just hope that she doesn’t rush into anything she’ll regret.

  8. MindyLou permalink
    6 February, 2008 9:43 PM

    Articles like this, although offer little in the way of information, do provoke a discussion – good or bad. Surprisingly for my lot, the opinion towards to it seemed positive, and “K” did speak to a fellow learner about it before, and during, talking to me about it. Transgender or not, this is something that “K” seems to have been mulling over for some time, and it seems this article that has spurred her to discuss the issues with others. As much as it annoys myself how the media trivialise gender, sexuality and sexual identity, sometimes it takes little things like this to trigger something in people that they have tried to subdue.


  1. Juste à temps pour la Saint-Valentin at AdamX

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: